Course withdrawal comments reveal academic and personal pressures
Updated Nov 18, 2026
A withdrawal form can record both a decision about study and a request to be heard. In Course Withdrawal in Higher Education, Sidni A. Justus, Gianni Bisio and Teresa P. Raczek examine students' explanations for leaving individual courses at Kennesaw State University in Georgia, alongside interviews with students who had withdrawn from a course and continued studying.
For UK Student Experience and institutional-research teams, the useful question is how to read the reason behind an administrative event. The study connects course difficulties with work, health, family responsibilities and the effort of balancing them.
What students wrote at the point of withdrawal
The researchers examined 20,555 withdrawal-form entries from 2022, of which 17,625 contained reasons they could code. These are withdrawal entries: the analysis concerns decisions about individual courses. The team developed a coding frame covering course-specific issues, changes in academic plans and personal circumstances, allowing an entry to contain more than one reason.
Course-specific reasons were the largest category, appearing in 37.9% of coded entries. They included difficulty with content or the professor, falling behind and poor assignment grades. Changes to a wider academic plan formed another prominent category: students described changing their major, managing their course load or protecting their grade point average. A withdrawal could therefore reflect a problem with a particular learning experience or a deliberate adjustment to a student's programme.
Personal circumstances entered those accounts too. Students described work schedules, caring responsibilities, financial difficulties and health concerns. Some explanations combined several pressures; others communicated exhaustion or distress without a detailed account of the circumstances. Reading only the administrative outcome would miss that difference between a course problem, a change of plan and a student struggling to manage daily life.
What retrospective interviews added
The researchers also surveyed and interviewed 39 students in autumn 2023 who had withdrawn from at least one course. These separate retrospective accounts described decisions made after disappointing results or a judgement that the workload had become unmanageable. Some students sought advice from tutors, advisers, family or friends; others decided for themselves.
Interviewees identified changes that might have helped them continue, including clearer information about course expectations, communication from teaching staff and understanding of employment commitments. Others reflected on their own use of support. Some described withdrawal positively as a way to reduce their course load, pursue another subject or continue with their remaining studies. The withdrawal forms and interviews offer different perspectives on these decisions.
The form responses also included disclosures of immediate safety concerns. The authors recommend review by trained staff so that a procedural form can lead to an appropriate response. This makes the handling of the comment part of the institutional process, alongside the coding of its theme.
Use the explanation to choose the next question
Our practical suggestion is to keep the original prompt and collection point attached to each account. Distinguish difficulty with course content, assessment expectations and access to help from the demands students describe outside study. Let a comment retain several relevant themes rather than forcing it into a single reason code. The comment-analysis pathway provides related guidance on definitions and review.
Agree who reviews time-sensitive disclosures and what students are told about the form's purpose and response arrangements. For a programme-level review, bring themes to the team able to act on the particular issue, then check the relevant brief, communication or support route with students. Our belonging and support pathway helps separate the experience of receiving support from the effort of reaching it.
Keep later reflections as a distinct source of insight. An interview can explore what students now make of their decision and what might have helped at the time. The student feedback analysis glossary explains the terms needed to describe comments, themes and counts clearly.
FAQ
Does withdrawing from a course always mean leaving university?
No. This study examines individual-course withdrawal. The interviewed students had continued studying and described a range of subsequent decisions.
What did the comments add to the administrative records?
They described course difficulties, changes to academic plans and personal pressures, sometimes within the same entry. Some also disclosed urgent concerns requiring a response.
What can a UK institution review locally?
Check what the withdrawal process asks students to explain, who reads those answers and how a concern reaches the responsible team. Retain the question and collection point when using comments for course review.
References
Justus, Sidni A., Gianni Bisio and Teresa P. Raczek (2026). Course Withdrawal in Higher Education: Exploring Emotional and Practical Factors Behind Student Non-Completion Decisions. Teaching & Learning Inquiry, 14, 1–18. Published 30 October 2026. https://doi.org/10.20343/teachlearninqu.14.54.
Request a walkthrough
Book a free Student Voice Analytics demo
See all-comment coverage, sector benchmarks, and reporting designed for OfS quality and NSS requirements.
- All-comment coverage with HE-tuned taxonomy and sentiment.
- Versioned outputs with TEF-ready reporting.
- Benchmarks and BI-ready exports for boards and Senate.
UK-hosted · No public LLM APIs · Same-day turnaround