How students describe teaching excellence
Updated Nov 06, 2026
What do students have in mind when they describe teaching as excellent? Claudine Fox, Martyn Parker and Emily Locker explored that question through a survey and follow-up discussions at one UK university.
The survey involved 79 students: 55 undergraduates and 24 postgraduate taught students. Two follow-up groups brought together five undergraduates and six postgraduate students to discuss examples from their experience.
What students valued
The researchers identified three themes in the discussions:
- Balanced, constructive support. Students described feedback that recognised strengths and explained how to improve, alongside an approachable response when they needed help.
- Attention to the learner. Accounts included access to teaching activities, material that reflected different perspectives and staff responding to student feedback.
- Growth and development. Students described opportunities to develop academic skills and connect learning with future professional work.
The themes describe what participants valued in their learning experience. Read the paper in Warwick’s research archive.
Bring examples into the review
Our suggestion is to ask students for a specific example before revising evaluation questions or teaching-award criteria. What did the teacher do, what happened in the learning activity and why did that matter to the student?
Compare the examples with the existing criteria. A description of useful feedback, for instance, can help a team examine whether its criteria recognise explanation, dialogue and the opportunity to apply advice.
Invite students to comment on the revised wording, record why it changed and review how it works in the next cycle. Keep space for different experiences across programmes and stages of study.
The teaching-awards and gender briefing explores patterns in nomination evidence. The student-partnership pathway helps connect students’ examples with a shared review process.
Correction, 7 September 2026: Earlier claims that survey correlations demonstrated improved wellbeing were removed.
Reference
Fox, C., Parker, M. and Locker, E. (2026; first published online 2025). The meaning of excellence in learning and teaching to students. Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, 51(4), 632–648. DOI: 10.1080/02602938.2025.2588681.
Request a walkthrough
Book a free Student Voice Analytics demo
See all-comment coverage, sector benchmarks, and reporting designed for OfS quality and NSS requirements.
- All-comment coverage with HE-tuned taxonomy and sentiment.
- Versioned outputs with TEF-ready reporting.
- Benchmarks and BI-ready exports for boards and Senate.
UK-hosted · No public LLM APIs · Same-day turnaround